
Theater review
THE FANTASTICKS
Two hours and five minutes, with one intermission. At the Hayes Theater, 240 West 44th Street.
“Try to remember”? How could we possibly forget?
That bouncy old heart-warmer “The Fantasticks” played off-Broadway for more than half a century — downtown at the Sullivan Street Playhouse for 42 years and then another nine at the Jerry Orbach Theater near Times Square until 2017. Its record stands as the longest-running musical in the world.
So, if you’re going to revive Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt’s classic show on Broadway less than a decade later, you better have a damn good reason.
I’d say director Christopher Gattelli and Second Stage Theater have found a pretty decent one for their upgraded and cute-as-ever production that opened Monday night at the Hayes Theater: They’ve swapped three of the roles’ genders. The two young lovers are now gay men, and their scheming fathers have morphed into meddling mothers.
For the most part, “The Fantasticks” is still pure bubblegum. This likable staging is not out to make any hard-hitting social statements. Well, I hope not. And the move doesn’t alter the bones of the piece in the same way that a similar maneuver did for Stephen Sondheim’s “Company” a few seasons back. The takeaway here is identical to what it would have been in 1960.
What the casting choices do, beneficially, is iron out some of those “Mad Men”-era wrinkles for 2026. For instance, one of the romantic leads is normally a girl named Luisa, and to today’s eyes and ears that ingenue comes off awfully ditzy. And two dads being obsessed with the marriage of their kids is, erm, a little weird. No longer a problem.
This musical is no stranger to alterations either. Back in 2006, the creators had to redo an upbeat comic song that mentioned rape. A lot. That their show was an adaptation of an 1894 French play no longer mattered. They changed the unfunny word to “abduction.”
Switching up the roles isn’t so heavy as that fix. The idea works, mostly, and allows for some credible and lovely reinterpretations of these famous parts by a few fabulous actors, especially Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles as the pesky parents.
Guns-a-blazin’ Kritzer plays Mildred and snappy Miles is Bessie May — the respective eccentric moms of Matt (Maxim Chlumecky) and Lewis (Nathan Levy). All through the boys’ childhoods, their ‘rents brewed up a fake feud to get the kids interested in each other. Adolescent rebellion and all that. Say “No!” and your spawn will do the opposite, right?
The women have gone so far as to build a wall between their houses. One of the twee-er aspects of this musical is that an actor plays said stack of bricks, a very fine dancer named Ahmad Simmons.
Smitten, Matt and Lewis meet in secret under moonlight and, by design, fall in love.
The greatest asset of “The Fantasticks” is its jaunty and tuneful score that’s a bit “Barber of Seville,” and a soupçon of “Maria” from “West Side Story.” Sometimes rollicking and often romantic, Jones and Schmidt built an ear-worm farm. And Levy and Chlumecky, with an adorable chemistry, croon the sublime first act songs such as “Much More” and “Metaphor” gorgeously and with an irrepressible modern energy.
Levy is sweet and spunky and has the tough job redefining his manic character to be, well, a guy. He goes berserk with Lewis’ narcissism and hyperactivity, embodying a recent-ish phrase — demon twink. Google it. I have neither the space nor inclination to explain. But that makes his calm moments all the more potent.
And Chlumecky has a stunner of a voice and a grounded, commanding presence as Matt, who wanders off into the real world in Act 2 and isn’t happy with what he finds there. As the old saying goes: Home is where the curtain call is.
Kritzer and Miles are campy and delightful, especially during their duets together. When they sing “Never Say No,” explaining their philosophy on raising children, they’re almost doing the “Hot Honey Rag” from “Chicago” by way of the Borscht Belt. The actresses clash and combine wonderfully. And because the Hayes is Broadway’s most intimate room, they can toy around with microscopic gestures and inflections.
Our guide is El Gallo, a traveling magician and troublemaker played by Zane Phillips. The hunky actor, making a confident Broadway debut, sings the musical’s most famous song, “Try to Remember,” in a soothing baritone that he hasn’t been able to show off in any of his movies or TV shows, like “Fire Island” and “Glamorous.”
The second act isn’t as boisterous or tidy as the first, which ends with a blissful “happily ever after.” Sadder and wiser, it’s about how harsh reality so often doesn’t live up to our fantasies and dreams. Hear, hear! Yet without Part Two, the show has no point. And fixating on its flaws is trite after five decades of success.
Even in 1960, Post critic Richard Watts Jr. wrote, “Indeed, so much that is pleasant goes on in ‘The Fantasticks’ that I feel almost ungrateful for adding my quibbles about its lack of consistent effectiveness.” Same, Dick. Same.
Those wobblier elements include a duo of Shakespearean actor characters, Henry (David Patrick Kelly) and Mortimer (Kevin Del Aguila), who, while amusingly played here, rely on clichéd old thee-ay-tuh jokes.
The revival has charming work from Gattelli, who has a tendency to stuff too much into his usually huge shows. He’s rightly restrained for this slimmer affair, nodding to the show’s humble origins while recognizing Broadway audiences expect a touch of glitz.
We witness that understanding during his opening flourish when a tableau of the Sullivan Street Playhouse’s “Fantasticks” “set” with a standing piano and a harp disappears to reveal the Hayes’ gleaming, stark-white stage. It’s a nice, nostalgic homage to the beginnings of a beautiful little show.
Gattelli tries to remember, and then, save for a few smart switcheroos, he follows, follows, follows.

