A stunning seaside town known for its golden beaches, charming harbour and vibrant arts scene is struggling under the impact of overtourism and second-home ownership. St Ives, a magical coastal town in Cornwall, is a top choice for many holidaymakers.
However, the locals in the area have been left disgruntled with the escalating prices of homes and local services. Its picture-perfect beaches have drawn millions over the years, but the influx has come at a steep cost. The town, with a population under 11,000, sees a massive seasonal surge, putting pressure on roads, waste management and public services.
Michael Bird, a resident of the town told The Guardian: “This beautiful town is buckling under the pressures of high-value overtourism and the relentless squeeze on what’s available for locals – the foundations, in other words, of sustainable community life.”
Mr Bird explained that when someone is having difficulty securing a long-term rental and is already burdened by high rent, it’s unlikely they’ll be able to lift their spirits by indulging in a £29 seafood linguine at a place that used to be a reasonably priced local café.
A 2016 referendum in St Ives saw a decisive move against second home ownership, with over 80% of voters endorsing a “principal residence” policy for new housing sales.
Local Ben Hodgkinson told the BBC: “Making housing affordable would be the number one challenge here. Local jobs are in short supply and wages are terrible.
“We wouldn’t be anywhere without tourism, but it pushes the prices up. It is a lovely place to be but lots of people can’t afford to stay here to live.”
Despite Cornwall’s ongoing attempts to curb the impact of second-home ownership on housing affordability, the issue remains deeply entrenched.
One glaring example came last year when Councillor Andrew Mitchell of Halsetown Ward in St Ives fiercely criticised a developer for exploiting a legal loophole that allowed hotel apartments—originally intended as part of an aparthotel—to be sold off as second homes and holiday lets.
He said: “A developer is hoping to steal from the community of St Ives at least 10-plus affordable homes which are due to this hotel being changed to apartments. It is not an aparthotel – it will never be an aparthotel.”

