Every December, millions of British households wrestle a giant turkey into the oven out of sheer festive habit. According to the British Poultry Council, a staggering 8-9 million turkeys are tucked into over the festive period. Yet when asked what truly belongs at the centre of the Christmas table, the country’s leading chefs, who work daily alongside Britain’s finest local butchers, are almost unanimous that turkey is not the best choice.
Despite its reputation for drying out, chefs agree it is easy to see why turkey remains Britain’s default festive roast. Mark Hartstone, chef-proprietor of La Fosse at Cranborne, says that turkey has been a status symbol on English tables since Tudor times, adding that once the tradition reached ordinary households, it simply stuck.
Will Hickton, head chef at The Club House on the Jurassic Coast, and Luke Davis, founder of Rockwater, both note that a single large bird offers undeniable value when feeding a crowd of 10 or more, providing both light and dark meat and guaranteed Boxing Day sandwiches.
Stuart Gillies, former Gordon Ramsay Group CEO and chef-restaurateur behind Number Eight in Sevenoaks, adds that turkey’s mild flavour acts as a blank canvas for stuffing and pigs in blankets. Even so, many professionals avoid it when cooking for their own families.
Will admits he skips turkey at home in favour of meats with bigger flavour. Alan Keery, chef-owner of NÀDAIR in Edinburgh, urged home cooks to “ditch the scrawny, gaunt-looking turkey” altogether.
What’s the best Christmas turkey alternative?
If you still want a centrepiece as impressive as a whole turkey, aged bone-in rib of beef emerged as a clear favourite among top kitchens. Chef Kim Woodward of The Coal Shed London and Brighton calls a properly aged rib of beef “incredibly special,” praising its deep flavour, natural fat, and rich crust when served with beef dripping gravy and horseradish.
Luke Davis, founder of Rockwater, told Express.co.uk: “My Christmas Day pick would be a two-bone rib of beef, with the fat left on. It gives you a good crust and leaves plenty of flavour in the roasting tin for the gravy.
“I’d serve it with the whipped horseradish cream we pair with roast sirloin on Sundays at Rockwater. Whipping the cream softens the heat of the horseradish, which works really well with a rich cut like rib.”
If you still crave festive poultry, several chefs suggest turning back the clock to Britain’s original Christmas bird. Both Luke Bryant, head chef at The Clockspire in Sherborne, and Mark Hartstone name roast goose as their number-one turkey alternative,
The Clockspire chef says that the old-fashioned flavour comes with a huge bonus: rendered fat for “some of the best roast spuds you’ll ever eat.” For smaller gatherings, Bryant suggests a rich roast duck, whereas Stuart Gillies favours a French-style capon, stuffed with onion, garlic, and herbs, and finished with a red-wine and cold-butter pan gravy.
What’s the best value cut of meat?
When asked which cut delivers maximum flavour without breaking the bank, the consensus among chefs was overwhelming: ask your butcher for pork shoulder.
Luke Bryant, Luke Davis, and Kim Woodward all crowned pork shoulder their ultimate budget hero, praising how its generous marbling and connective tissue melt down during a long, slow roast into succulent, pull-apart meat.
To get the best results, Luke Davis advises asking your butcher to leave the skin on and score it, then roasting the joint over onions and apples to catch the juices while achieving crisp crackling.
Luke Bryant recommends rubbing the shoulder with salt, garlic, and rosemary before slow-roasting it with a splash of local cider, while Kim Woodward suggests blasting the oven at the end to blister the crackling to perfection.
Budget-conscious shoppers have plenty of other butcher-approved options, too. Will Hickton recommends slow-cooked beef brisket for its rich flavour and low price, while Alan Keery champions a one-tray spiced lamb shoulder or pork belly roasted directly over chunked potatoes, carrots, and onions.
Alternatively, both Stuart Gillies and Mark Hartstone suggest buying just the turkey thighs or legs and asking your butcher to bone them out, so you can roll them around pork sausage meat and herbs for a fraction of the cost of a whole bird.
Ensure our latest lifestyle headlines always appear at the top of your Google Search by making us a Preferred Source. Click here to activate or add us as a Preferred Source in your Google search settings

