When it comes to hits, even the most seasoned musicians can misjudge what will resonate with the public. And for Rod Stewart, one of Britain’s most beloved rock and roll voices, the path to a chart-topping anthem was anything but straightforward.
Despite his growing reputation after stints with The Faces and the Jeff Beck Group, not every track he brought to the studio was met with enthusiasm from his bandmates.
In the early 1970s, Stewart was stepping out as a songwriter in his own right. His album Every Picture Tells a Story marked a shift from his blues-rock roots to a more rustic and introspective sound.
Yet when Stewart introduced what would become one of his most celebrated tracks, the reaction from his band was far from encouraging.
Guitarist Martin Quittenton admitted, “We didn’t think it was very good. Never in anyone’s wildest dreams was it a pop standard.” Even keyboardist Ian McLagan dismissed his own contribution as “rubbish” compared to his work with The Faces. The prevailing sentiment in the studio was that this song simply lacked the melody or energy to make any impact on the charts.
The song in question was none other than ‘Maggie May’ – now regarded as a cornerstone of classic rock and one of Rod Stewart’s signature tunes.
‘Maggie May’ almost didn’t make it out of the studio. Its unconventional structure – with its confessional lyrics about heartache and regret – didn’t fit the mould of an obvious radio hit. The track paired Stewart’s raspy vocals with shimmering acoustic arrangements, far removed from the electrifying rockers that had defined him up to that point.
Despite initial doubts, the simplicity and honesty of ‘Maggie May’ proved irresistible to listeners. Rather than chase trends or overthink arrangements, Stewart delivered a raw, relatable story that audiences found deeply authentic – even if some lyrics ventured into surprisingly candid territory for mainstream airplay at the time.
The track’s universal appeal lay in its emotional vulnerability rather than musical complexity, and ‘Maggie May’ quickly silenced sceptics.
It soared to number one on both sides of the Atlantic in 1971, topping charts in the UK and US while propelling Every Picture Tells a Story to international acclaim.
The single became synonymous with Stewart himself and remains a staple of British popular music decades later.