By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept

Amed Post

Breaking News,magazine, sport, life

Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Reading: I tried mince pies from Asda, M&S, Aldi, Lidl and Sainsbury’s
Share
Font ResizerAa

Amed Post

Breaking News,magazine, sport, life

Search
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
Life & Style

I tried mince pies from Asda, M&S, Aldi, Lidl and Sainsbury’s

amedpost
Last updated: November 15, 2026 4:37 am
amedpost
Published: November 15, 2026
Share
SHARE


Contents
  • Asda mince pies – £1.42
  • Sainsbury’s mince pies – £1.19
  • Aldi mince pies – £1.19
  • Lidl mince pies – £2.79
  • Winner – M&S mince pies – £2.50

Mince pies

I put five different supermarket mince pies to the test (Image: Nicola Roy)

I know you don’t want to hear it, but we’re officially half way through November, which means it’s basically Christmas. The time absolutely flies during this period, meaning we’ve got to be prepared for the celebrations – which always involve a lot of food.

It’s the season for treating yourself for sure, and one festive snack that has stood the test of time is the humble mince pie. Some love them, some hate them – but I’m a massive fan, especially when they’re served warm with a little cream. But which supermarket does the best mince pie? I decided to test out five different varieties to find out.

Mince pies

Mince pies are one of my favourite festive snacks (Image: Nicola Roy)

It may not even be December yet, but that hasn’t stopped most supermarkets from decking the halls and filling the aisles with endless Christmas-themed snacks and gifts. This has been the case probably since mid-September, but it never fails to get me in the festive mood, and I definitely felt it as I was walking around.

The only two shops near me that didn’t seem to have any mince pies was Tesco and Co-op. However, I managed to grab boxes from Aldi, Lidl, Sainsbury’s, M&S and Asda, although since some were small stores, the options were a little limited in some.

There were some that definitely looked more premium – the M&S brown butter and cognac ones to be precise – but they were pricier and so to keep things fair, I made sure no box was more than £2.80. After trying them all, there was one clear winner, and one I’d never ever buy again.

Asda mince pie

The Asda mince pie was really tasty (Image: Nicola Roy)

Asda mince pies – £1.42

I’m not sure if this is cheating or not, but these are usually £2.84 so they’d have been out of my budget if they hadn’t been on a Rollback. They were definitely one of the most premium-tasting, in my opinion, and definitely worthy of the higher price tag.

The pastry was very buttery and crumbly, but not too stodgy, which is a very common problem for mince pies. The most important part, however, is the fruity filling, and this one was very delicious.

It was very nicely spiced, but as you can see from the picture, it probably wasn’t the most generous of fillings. Having said that, the overall design was very pretty too, and I always appreciate a nice dusting of icing sugar.

Sainsburys mince pie

The Sainsbury’s mince pie was disappointing (Image: Nicola Roy)

Sainsbury’s mince pies – £1.19

In my opinion, it’s pretty rare that you find something in Sainsbury’s for the same price as Aldi. But these mince pies were an example, and a box of six set me back £1.19.

Sadly, the cheaper price was definitely reflected in the taste and texture. As I sliced the mince pie in half, the pastry was much harder under the knife than the buttery-soft Asda one had been.

The edges along the top of the pie were similarly crispy, and the fruit filling wasn’t much better. Very little actual fruit and way too sweet, and they were also tiny. I probably wouldn’t buy these again. I’m sure Sainsbury’s do a more premium version which I’d be willing to bet is a lot more delicious, but it sadly wasn’t available at my local.

Aldi mince pie

Aldi’s mince pies were extremely average (Image: Nicola Roy)

Aldi mince pies – £1.19

As mentioned, these were the same price as the Sainsbury’s version, but they were only very slightly better. Again, the pastry was just not as soft as you’d expect from a mince pie, and there was no crumbly element at all.

On a positive note, the filling was a lot nicer. There was more depth of flavour rather than being too sugary or syrupy, but again, you can see from the picture that it’s barely even half full.

Another one I’d probably avoid buying again, but it’s not the worst thing I’ve ever eaten. And again, you get what you pay for, so Aldi’s pricier versions are probably delicious too.

Lidl mince pie

Lidl’s mince pie was very nearly my favourite (Image: Nicola Roy)

Lidl mince pies – £2.79

These were such a pleasant surprise. Lidl has disappointed me in the past, but thankfully this wasn’t the case for their mince pies, although surprisingly they were the most expensive of the bunch but the only ones I spotted when I was browsing.

The pastry was perfect, I loved the festive star design, and it had a satisfying crumble to it. Sweet but not too cloying, it contrasted well with the fruity filling, which was warm and spicy.

I’d argue that these were worth the money, but still it’s slightly more than I would expect to pay in Lidl, when the Asda ones were probably just as good – and discounted too. Nevertheless, it was delicious, and I’d definitely buy again.

M&S mince pies

The M&S mince pies look like nothing special, but they were the best (Image: Nicola Roy)

Winner – M&S mince pies – £2.50

This has got to be one of the most boring-looking mince pies I’ve ever come across. Where’s the fun design?

However, don’t let this put you off. This was the most delicious mince pie out of the bunch – just look at the perfect pastry-to-fruit ratio. You couldn’t have packed any more in there.

I was concerned this would be quite hard like some of the others, but it was pleasantly soft and crumbly. These were the most basic ones I could find at M&S, but as mentioned, they had some more premium ones that looked absolutely stunning too.

But if you don’t want to break the bank, this £2.50 pack is an excellent choice. Even Santa would be proud.

Curry tastes just like a takeaway if you ditch the pan for better appliance
Andy Burnham issued urgent job loss warning over UK car industry
Vet urges all pet owners to stop leaving dog toys in 1 risky place
Princess Kate makes surprise U-turn on poignant Remembrance tradition | Royal | News
How to make your home feel 10C warmer without heating

Subscribe

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

[mc4wp_form]

Share This Article
Facebook Email Print
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© AMED POST Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?