There used to be something called Godwin’s Law: “As an online discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches one.” But bring Israel into the equation, and the speed with which the Holocaust is invoked appears to increase exponentially. Gone is the idea that a person is seen to lose a debate by resorting to such a cheap and lazy analogy. Instead, it now seems essential to wax lyrical about how Jews, once the victim, have become the persecutor.
Bob Geldof did this to impassioned effect in an opinion piece published in today’s [Jul 24] Express. I share his outrage at the humanitarian situation in Gaza (though not his inability to utter the two Hs, Hamas and hostages), and will defend his right to criticise any country in the strongest terms.
I just deplore that he has to immediately reach for the Shoah (in the first, second and third paragraphs) in order to do it. It should not be necessary to point out that something can be tragic, outrageous or even criminal without it being on a par with the industrial shooting, gassing and incineration of two thirds of European Jewry. It should not be necessary to point out that such a cataclysm is never a handy test for its victims to pass or fail.
No-one has put this better than Booker-winning novelist Howard Jacobson, who said that “the Holocaust is invoked to awaken a sympathy that can then be turned against the people… deemed unworthy of it. The Holocaust becomes a sort of university. An educational experience. A great learning opportunity, you might say”.
Geldof will, I am sure, argue that he was careful only to write of Israelis, rather than Jews. But it is only Israel’s Jews – not its Arab or Christian citizens – to whom he can be referring when he speaks of “the titanic enormity of your own past”, “similar images of your own historic horror” and dehumanising “as you once so cruelly were”.
Anti-Jewish racists have spent decades taking a peculiar kind of glee ignoring the intricate history and geopolitics in favour of the cod psychology that Jews are simply visiting their Nazi-era trauma on the Palestinians. They must be rejoicing that versions of this formula are now being given validation by a secular saint such as Geldof. But the Holocaust was not a moral lesson for Jews or Israelis to learn – any more than it is an acceptable stick to now beat them with.

