California’s sanctuary-state policies are undermining public safety and forcing immigration agents into costly, time-consuming street arrests instead of taking custody of criminal undocumented immigrants directly from jails, according to a top law enforcement official.
US Attorney for the Central District of California Bill Essayli said sanctuary policies have dismantled what he described as a once-cooperative system that kept higher-risk individuals from returning to the streets.
“The entire state of California is a sanctuary now, by state law,” Essayli told The California Post.
That escalating concern has fueled an enforcement push dubbed Operation Guardian Angel, a coordinated federal initiative targeting deportable individuals in county custody before they’re released back into the community.
The operation, announced last year by the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Central District of California, brings together ICE, the FBI, the DEA, the U.S. Marshals Service, and other federal agencies.
Officials say the goal is to identify criminal undocumented immigrants in local jails, secure federal arrest warrants ahead of release, and prevent what they describe as avoidable street-level apprehensions once individuals re-enter public life.
At the center of the effort is a reliance on fingerprinting and jail booking records to flag individuals with prior deportation history.
Task forces typically begin reviewing county jail bookings across the state in the early morning hours, often around 3 a.m., cross-checking fingerprints against federal databases in near real time.
Those who show prior removals can face federal felony charges for illegal reentry, allowing prosecutors to obtain warrants quickly and take custody before release from local detention.
“This program only works, if we know who they are,” Essayli said.
First-time offenders in non-state prisons can easily slip back into the community under current state laws.
Essayli added that the financial burden of bypassing sanctuary policies could ultimately reach “hundreds of million, if not, billions,” when accounting for enforcement costs and broader impacts.
He said that under previous practices, immigration detainers allowed jail inmates to be transferred directly into federal custody after their local cases concluded, avoiding the need for post-release enforcement operations.
“Prior to these laws, we would work cooperatively with local police and jails and so when an illegal immigrant was arrested or charged or convicted they would work with immigration officials to place detainers on them and then once they’re done with their local or state proceedings they would be handed over to immigration for deportation,” Essayli said.
Now, he said, many county jails refuse to honor detainers, forcing federal authorities into more resource-intensive efforts to locate individuals only after they have been released into communities.
“Blue states think they’re protecting illegal immigrants, but they’re just making things worse on them,” he said. “Instead of just being deported, they’re going to have a felony.”
Essayli also pointed to what he described as a structural split between state prisons and county jails.
“There is a loophole in that prisoners in the state prison, which is run by the governor, (Newsom) has the discretion on whether to hand someone over to ICE or not.”
He said Gov. Gavin Newsom retains discretion over transfers from state prisons, while sheriffs and police chiefs are restricted at the county level.
“You’ll hear Newsom often say ‘we’re not a sanctuary state, we handed over 3,000 felons,’ that is for political cover so he can hand over literally the worst of the worst. He has the discretion to hand (all of) them over, but the sheriffs, the police chiefs have zero discretion, they’re not allowed to, the governor can do it if he wants to, that’s the state of the law in California.”
Essayli noted that most offenders never reach state prison custody.
“Basically, you don’t go to state prison unless you murder someone,” he said.
He added that offenses such as theft, DUI, and domestic violence are typically handled at the county level, where federal transfer options are more limited.
“We don’t want to wait until an illegal immigrant commits a murder, we want to deport them before that.”
In a recent and tragic instance, a deportable individual released due to non-cooperation state policies went on to murder two women and an infant.