Josh Gad and Andrew Rannells have re-opened their copies of “The Book of Mormon.”
The stars, who originated the roles of Elder Cunningham and Elder Price on Broadway, are coming back to the Eugene O’Neill Theatre from June 9-14 to celebrate the 15th anniversary of Trey Parker and Matt Stone’s Tony and Olivier Award-winning musical.
They’ll be joined by Tony winner Nikki M. James (Nabulungi), and Tony nominee Rory O’Malley (Elder McKinley) at the “Magical Mormon Mystery Week’s” worth of shows.
If you’d like to see the iconic thespians “perform select scenes and songs alongside the current cast” — with no two performances being the same (!) — tickets are available for all seven shows.
At the time of publication, the lowest price we could find for any one show was $226 including fees on StubHub.
Other productions have seats starting anywhere from $228 to $270 including fees.
“You won’t know who you’re getting [on the night of the show you go to],” Parker, Stone and Robert Lopez told Stephen Colbert while breaking the exciting news.
Parker then added “I’m actually going to play Joseph Smith and Jesus.”
In addition to Parker, Playbill reports that “Stone, and Lopez as well as Broadway’s original Mormon and Ugandan ensembles at certain performances, plus other surprise guests from the Mormon family” will pop up throughout the week.
For the uninitiated, “The Book of Mormon” tells the story of a mismatched pair of missionaries who ship off to Uganda to convert local villagers to, you guessed it, Mormonism.
Current cast members spearheading the ensemble include Kevin Clay (Elder Price), Diego Enrico (Elder Cunningham) and Sydney Quildon (Nabulungi).
“…underneath the profanity, the show’s actually really sweet,” The Post reported back in March 2011. “…Parker and Stone don’t make fun of Mormons per se. Or they don’t make fun of them any more or less than they make fun of a lot of other things and people.”
To make sure you’re fully up to speed, our team has everything you need to know and more about “The Book of Mormon” with Josh Gad and Andrew Rannells.
“The Book of Mormon” with Andrew Rannells and Josh Gad ticket prices
All “Magical Mormon Mystery Week” dates, show start times and links to the cheapest tickets available can be found here:
| “The Book of Mormon” June 9-14 dates | StubHub prices start at |
|---|---|
| Tuesday, June 9 7 p.m. | $270 (including fees) |
| Wednesday, June 10 7 p.m. | $228 (including fees) |
| Thursday, June 11 7 p.m. | $228 (including fees) |
| Friday, June 12 7 p.m. | $226 (including fees) |
| Saturday, June 13 2 p.m. | $250 (including fees) |
| Saturday, June 13 7 p.m. | $259 (including fees) |
| Sunday, June 14 2 p.m. | $228 (including fees) |
“The Book of Mormon” tickets
Outside of June 9-14, “The Book of Mormon” is chugging along at the Eugene O’Neill Theatre with no end in sight.
If you’d like to see the tenth-longest running show in Broadway history that Entertainment Weekly calls “the funniest musical of all time,” shows take place Tuesday through Sunday.
Matinees go down at 2 p.m. on Saturdays and Sundays.
The musical runs 2 hours and 30 minutes with a 15-minute intermission. You can expect to get out of an evening show at 9:30 p.m.
Want to find the show that makes the most sense for your wallet and schedule?
You can find “The Book of Mormon’s” complete Broadway calendar here.
“The Book of Mormon” cast
Although Gad, Rannells, James and O’Malley aren’t regularly at the Eugene O’Neill Theatre these days, here’s who you can find at the playhouse these days.
Kevin Clay (Elder Price) is a “proud graduate” of Penn State University and has performed at the Pittsburgh Civic Light Opera, Music Theatre Wichita and Wagon Wheel Theatre.
Diego Enrich (Elder Cunningham) made his Broadway debut with “The Book of Mormon.” Prior to joining the cast, he acted as Cunningham on the North American tour of the show from 2024-25.
Sydney Quildon (Nabulungi) debuted on Broadway with “The Book of Mormon” as well. She’s a Hartt School grad and also starred as Ariel in “The Little Mermaid” before linking up with the ensemble.
Charlie Franklin (Elder McKinley) returned to “The Book of Mormon” after working elsewhere. He’s also appeared in “Succession” and “The Loudest Voice.”
Jacques C. Smith (Mafala Hatimbi) may look familiar. He previously inhabited the role of Benny in “Rent” and popped up in “General Hospital,” “Law & Order,” “ER,” “CSI: Miami” and “Oz” where he was a series regular.
Funny musicals on Broadway
“The Book of Mormon” isn’t the only gut-busting comedy (with songs!) on the Great White Way this year.
Here are just five of our favorite funny musicals you won’t want to miss these next few months.
• “Titanique”
• “The Rocky Horror Show”
• “Little Shop of Horrors”
• “Operation Mincemeat”
• “Death Becomes Her”
Prefer a concert? Check out our list of all the biggest artists on tour in 2026 to find the show of your dreams.
This article was written by Matt Levy, New York Post live events reporter. Levy stays up-to-date on all the latest tour announcements from your favorite musical artists and comedians, as well as Broadway openings, sporting events and more live shows – and finds great ticket prices online. Since he started his tenure at the Post in 2022, Levy has reviewed a Bruce Springsteen concert and interviewed Melissa Villaseñor of SNL fame, to name a few. Please note that deals can expire, and all prices are subject to change.