BUFFALO — In a season that, regardless of how far the Islanders go, will always be remembered as the debut campaign of Matthew Schaefer, their rookie phenom made some more history Tuesday night. But, in the context of a 4-3 loss to the Sabres, he didn’t want to focus on it.
Schaefer’s assist on Anders Lee’s third-period goal gave him 57 points for the season, moving him past Stefan Persson (1977-78) and into first place all time for most points by an Islanders rookie defenseman. He’ll enter Friday’s game one point behind Phil Housley for most points by an 18-year-old defenseman in NHL history, and Schaefer has collected 20 points — including seven goals — across the past 20 games.
“Obviously you hear things and people say stuff,” Schaefer said when asked if he was aware of breaking the record, “but, I mean, I don’t really care. I mean, obviously, it’s something pretty cool, and there’s so many great players that have gone through this organization and things like that. I’ve put up so many points, but at the end of the day, we’re in a playoff push right now and this was a big game.”
At that moment, Schaefer was more concerned about being on the ice for the Sabres’ game-winning goal, when Alex Tuch pulled possession around the net and fed Peyton Krebs in front. “I mean, if that doesn’t go in it’s still a tie game,” he said. Schaefer was in front of the crease when the puck snuck past him and went right to Krebs’ stick.
And that moment was enough to take away from his historic night.
The Islanders were forced to operate without a piece of their power play and a consistent offensive producer Tuesday, as Simon Holmstrom didn’t play due to an upper-body injury and was listed as day to day by head coach Patrick Roy.
That meant Anthony Duclair, who hadn’t appeared in a game since March 21 amid another roller coaster of a season, slotted back into the lineup, skating alongside Mathew Barzal and Brayden Schenn on the second line. He finished with 11:29 of ice time and didn’t attempt a shot. Holmstrom, who has collected 19 goals and 30 points this season, had finished the Islanders’ game Monday.
When asked what he wanted to see from Duclair during his return to the lineup, Roy, during his answer pregame, cited his connection with Barzal earlier in the season. Duclair strung together 13 points in 13 January games — including a hat trick against the Devils on Jan. 6.
He only managed one point across the eight games he has appeared in since, though, but Roy wanted to see if that Barzal chemistry could work again.
Roy didn’t think the fight between Lee and Sam Carrick — which Carrick initiated to stand up for a hit by Lee on the Sabres’ Josh Norris in the second period — was warranted. Carrick remained down on the ice with an apparent left shoulder injury and exited with a trainer.
“I thought that was — it was a very good non-call,” Roy said. “I don’t think we needed that fight personally, but, I mean, [Lee] looked good.”
The AHL Board of Governors unanimously approved the relocation of Bridgeport — the Islanders minor league affiliate — to Hamilton, Ontario, the league announced. The move will happen for the 2026-27 season.
