
Cynthia Diekema, 61, was canoeing with her husband when tragedy struck (Image: D.L. Miller Funeral Home)
A woman was dragged underwater and mauled to death by an 11ft alligator while on holiday with her husband, who desperately tried to save her as the terrifying attack unfolded. Cynthia Diekema, 61, was canoeing with her husband David along Tiger Creek in Polk County, Florida, when the couple’s boat struck the enormous reptile.
The pair had set off from Lake Kissimmee State Park in an 11ft plastic canoe and were paddling through shallow water when they spotted several alligators. Moments before the attack, Cynthia warned her husband they were “about to go right over top of one”.
But their canoe struck an alligator resting on the bottom of the creek, causing the startled animal to thrash violently. The impact tipped the boat over, throwing both Cynthia and David into the water at around 4pm.
In a statement to police, David described the horrifying moment he saw the alligator clamped around his wife’s torso. He desperately tried to pull her free for several minutes, but was unable to release her from the animal’s powerful jaws.
During the struggle, David said his wife initially appeared alert before developing a “puzzled look on her face” and losing the ability to speak. The alligator then struck David with its tail, knocking him underwater.

Cynthia Diekema, 61, was canoeing with her husband when the attack unfolded (Image: Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission)
It briefly released Cynthia before biting her again on the shoulder.
David managed to get back to his feet and made another attempt to rescue his wife.
But the enormous reptile then performed what is known as a “death roll”, twisting its body violently before swimming away with Cynthia.
A death roll is a powerful manoeuvre used by alligators to disable and dismember their prey.
David had lost his mobile phone when the canoe overturned, leaving him unable to call emergency services.
Instead, he scooped water out of the overturned canoe and paddled north towards Lake Kissimmee in search of help.
He was eventually rescued by a person travelling in an airboat.
Wildlife officers launched a search after the attack on May 6, 2025, and discovered Cynthia’s body around 20 minutes later. Paramedics pronounced her dead at the scene.
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. Read our Privacy Policy
A medical examiner subsequently determined that she had died from blunt force injuries inflicted by the alligator, including the loss of her right arm below the shoulder. Her death was ruled an accident.
The alligator was caught and put down by trappers at around 7.30pm that evening. Officers returned to the creek the following day and removed another potentially dangerous alligator.
Cynthia was from Paw Paw, Michigan, and is survived by her husband, two children and two grandchildren.
Her obituary paid tribute to a woman who “radiated her inner and outer beauty in all she did and had unconditional love for everyone”.
It added: “She cherished her family and every moment and adventure they spent together.”
The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission expressed its deepest sympathies to Cynthia’s family and friends following the tragedy.

